Published on November 27, 2023, 5:22 pm
Artificial Intelligence (AI) and its impact on various industries have become a hot topic of discussion. One area where AI is causing some concerns is in the field of web content generation. Recent SEO experiments have revealed that Google’s search engine struggles to handle AI-generated content effectively, opening up new challenges for the tech giant.
AI poses a twofold threat to Google’s core Internet search business. First, chatbots powered by AI, like ChatGPT, have the potential to become the primary way people search for digital information. This means that traditional methods of searching through libraries of websites may become less important over time.
The second threat is more immediate, as the amount of AI-generated content on the web continues to grow rapidly. This flood of near-duplicate content poses a significant challenge for Google in providing accurate and relevant search results.
To illustrate this issue further, a study conducted by Newsguard in June highlighted how news sites solely relying on AI-generated content are quickly gaining traction. These sites often publish hundreds or even thousands of articles per day, generating massive amounts of traffic and revenue with strategic spam tactics.
One example is a site called “gameishard.gg” that reached millions of readers almost overnight by using generic AI content distributed through Google channels like Search and Discover. Despite being aware of such sites, Google seems hesitant to penalize them outright. Instead, it emphasizes determining the usefulness of AI content while maintaining an air of pseudo-transparency regarding its ranking algorithms.
However, one SEO professional named Jake Ward recently pushed the boundaries by conducting what he calls an “SEO heist.” He used AI tools to scan competitors’ websites and generate new content ideas based on existing content structures. Using this method, Ward published 1,800 articles within hours, leading to an astonishing 3.6 million visits and prominent positioning on Google’s first page for relevant keywords.
Ward received criticism from fellow SEO experts who viewed his actions as dubious, accusing him of polluting the internet. This highlights a fundamental problem for Google: if such tactics continue to be successful, it undermines the integrity of its search results.
Nevertheless, solutions for Google may lie in shifting towards more verified human content and relying on professional authors and editors. Already, Google has started displaying author names alongside publication names in news stories. Social media posts are also appearing in Google’s “Perspectives” search. These changes show a potential direction where human integration becomes more prominent within Google’s products.
However, relying solely on human-generated content comes with its own set of challenges. Negotiations with news publishers worldwide have shown that Google is reluctant to pay for third-party content despite profiting from it. Therefore, another scenario emerges where Google itself becomes a leading AI publisher, further advancing its Search Generative Experience projects like Gemini.
The future success of this approach depends on whether AI-generated content can match the reliability of information provided by humans. Today’s AI systems still require significant improvement to avoid spreading misinformation unconsciously.
Additionally, Google must navigate this transition carefully without losing significant market share to competitors. Examples like Jake Ward’s experiment raise doubts about the smoothness of such a transition. However, given the fast-paced nature of technological advancements and Google’s resources, it remains too soon to draw definitive conclusions about their future in the AI landscape.
In conclusion, the rise of AI-generated content presents both opportunities and challenges for search engine giant Google. As AI continues to evolve rapidly, finding effective methods to handle and prioritize information while delivering accurate search results remains critical for maintaining relevance in an ever-changing digital landscape.